Friday, 10 November 2017

1963-64 - Part four (Walsall & Blues both in trouble)

Posted by Tony Hutton


SATURDAY 11TH JANUARY 1964

LEAGUE DIVISION THREE AT FELLOWS PARK, WALSALL

WALSALL 3 (Matthews 2, Roper) MANSFIELD TOWN 1 (Wagstaffe)    Attendance 4,376

Tennant; Gregg, Sharples; Roper, McPherson, Dudley;
Meek, Matthews, Wiggin, Hodgkisson, Foster;

Treharne; Jones, Humble; Chapman S., Gill, Morris;
Wagstaff, Govan, Hall, Chapman R., Scanlon;

Referee: L.J. Harmer, Bolton



18 year old David Tennant made his debut in goal for Walsall.







Critics of Walsall's recent poor form demonstrated by putting a placard on the centre of the pitch which said 'you buy or we go' before the kick off. The Saddlers had lost eight of their last ten games and introduced 18 year old goalkeeper David Tennant for his first ever league game.

Matthews, after going close for Walsall early on, put them ahead after only six minutes. It was a sloppy goal with full back Humble mis-kicked and just teed the ball up for Matthews to score with ease. Walsall were well in charge and went further ahead after 13 minutes. Hodgkisson sent a wonderful pass out to Meek on the right wing, who pulled it back from the goal line. Centre forward Wiggin headed it down to Matthews, who hit it on the volley past Treharne.

Scanlon, the former Manchester United winger, had the best chance for Mansfield when he broke away through the middle. However the young Walsall goalkeeper Tennant showed good anticipation to race out and clear the ball. This gave him added confidence which he showed when jumping high to make a good catch from a high centre.

Mansfield did pull one back after 35 minutes when right winger Ken Wagstaff appeared in the inside left position and scored from 20 yards out with Tennant diving the wrong way, either due to a deflection or being unsighted by his own defenders. Mansfield continued to threaten until the interval but Walsall just managed to hang on to their lead. Half time 2-1.

After another period of Mansfield pressure Walsall went further ahead after Foster had been fouled.
From the free kick just outside the penalty area Dudley floated a perfect cross for Roper racing in to head it over the advancing goalkeeper. Mansfield came back strongly again and Tennant was forced into several good saves, doing well to keep out both Hall and Roy Chapman.




SATURDAY 1ST FEBRUARY, 1964

LEAGUE DIVISION THREE AT FELLOWS PARK, WALSALL

WALSALL 1 (Matthews) SHREWSBURY TOWN 1 (Clarke)

Tennant; Gregg, Sharples; Roper, McPherson, Dudley;
Meek, Matthews, Wiggin, Hodgkisson, Foster;

Boswell; Wright, Hemsley; Harley, Dolby, Brodie;
Gregson, Ross, Clarke, Middleton, Taylor;

Referee:- J. Mitchell, Prescot, Lancs.




FRIDAY 28TH FEBRUARY 1964                                    Attendance 9,518

LEAGUE DIVISION THREE AT FELLOWS PARK, WALSALL

WALSALL 0 MILLWALL 2

Tennant; Gregg, Sharples; Roper, McPherson, Dudley;
Smith, Matthews, Llewellyn, Hodgkisson, Meek;

Stepney; Gilchrist, Cripps; Anderson, Snowdon, Wilson;
Gray, Julians, Terry, Jones, Haverty;

Referee:- S.B. Stokes, Nottingham





After two good wins against Barnsley and Port Vale the Saddlers slumped to yet another home defeat against a confident Millwall side. Little was seen of new centre forward Bert Llewellyn, signed from Northampton, who scored a hat trick at Barnsley in only his second appearance.

Match report from Birmingham Post.

An inept display by Walsall caused them to suffer their first home defeat for two months and gave lowly placed Millwall two valuable points. Walsall were hustled out of their stride by the quick moving Millwall forwards and their own attack could never produce any rhythm. The promptings of Hodgkisson were not always accurate and the possible menace of Llewellyn was snuffed out by a solid performance by Snowden.

Millwall's own forwards were far from convincing, but they had more bite, with the dual spearheads of Julians and Terry who often had McPherson in trouble. Milwall, kicking down the slope, began with a series of attacks which put the Walsall defence under severe pressure. The home side's only shot in the first ten minutes came from a long range effort by Matthews which Stepney saved safely.

The goalkeeper was in trouble a few minutes later when a badly judged back pass from Cripps forced him dive at the feet of the lively Llewellyn and he had to have treatment from the trainer before continuing. A minute later, Gray, the Millwall player manager, making his first appearance for the club sent over a dangerous centre but Haverty's shot was just over the bar. Millwall might well have gone ahead after twenty three minutes but Jones powerful shot hit his own centre forward.

Julians got the ball into the net four minutes later but was clearly offside. Terry clearly disagreed with the referee's decision and had his name taken when he continued to argue. Julians got Millwall their inevitable goal to give Millwall the lead in the thirty fifth minute. He passed to Jones and made ground quickly to accept the return and pushed the ball past the advancing Tennant. This goal brought more life into the hesitant Walsall forwards but Smith headed just wide from their best chance.

With the slope in their favour Walsall looked more dangerous at the start of the second half and Stepney had to dive to cut out a dangerous cross from Smith. But there was still a lack of method in the Walsall advances and the crowd were beginning to express their displeasure. Millwall were little better and Terry wasted an interception of a back pass from Gregg by blazing the ball high and wide. 

Millwall went further ahead when a header from Terry was going wide but Julians arrived suddenly on the scene to nod the ball wide of the stranded Tennant. Meek had a great chance to reduce the arrears seven minutes from the end but the outside left only half hit his shot and Gilchrist cleared.




SATURDAY 29TH FEBRUARY, 1964

LEAGUE DIVISION ONE AT ST ANDREWS, BIRMINGHAM

BIRMINGHAM CITY 1 (Thomson) TOTTENHAM HOTSPURS 2 (Jones, Greaves pen.)

Withers; Martin, Green; Hennessey, Smith, Beard;
Auld, Bloomfield, Thomson, Leek, Thwaites;

Hollowbread; Baker, Hopkins; Beal, Norman, Marchi;
Jones, White, Brown, Greaves, Dyson;

Referee:-J. W. Bullough, Bolton



Top of the table Spurs came to St Andrews with a three point lead from Liverpool, who have two games in hand. The Blues on the other hand were just one place above the two relegation spots with only Bolton and Ipswich below them. Since Christmas Blues have only won one game which was a surprising 2-1 away win at Manchester United. Their last two games were both away on Merseyside and they lost to both Everton and Liverpool.

Bertie Auld, Birmingham's Scottish winger, was back after a month's suspension and was soon in the action with an inswinging free kick which Thomson nearly got a touch to in the crowded goalmouth.
Spurs had new signing from Arsenal Laurie Brown at centre forward, although he is normally a centre half who lost his place to Ian Ure at Highbury. He too was soon involved when he headed a Baker free kick over the bar.

Brown had another chance beating TrevorSmith to the ball but Withers made a good save. Somehow the game lacked sparkle and there was little goalmouth action for some time. Greaves was off the field briefly receiving attention to an injury but when he returned his corner led to Spurs eventually taking the lead after 36 minutes. Norman out jumped Beard, the ball bounced awkwardly in the crowded penalty are and Jones scored with a point blank header.

Greaves nearly added to the score with a long range shot brilliantly saved by Withers before Thomson made the miss of the match for Blues. He beat Norman with ease but with only the goalkeeper to beat completely mis-kicked and the ball trickled well wide of goal. Blues had one or two more good chances before the interval but could not convert them into goals. Half time 0-1.

For the second half Blues switched their wingers so that Auld could return to his more familiar position of outside left. After a close range effort from Greaves Birmingham came back hard with Auld much more involved in the action. In the 53rd minute the Scottish winger took the ball from Smith after a fine run up field by the big centre half. He went round Baker on the outside and pulled the ball back into the middle for Thomson to push home from close range.  All square and Blues hopefull of pulling off a surprise win.

However, they failed to continue their pressure on the Spurs goal and eventually after 67 minutes conceded a penalty which Jimmy Greaves put away with ease. Once in the lead Spurs defence tightened up and Blues were really outplayed by the end of the game despite all their frantic efforts to get an equaliser. More trouble for Blues but Spurs even without some of their big names looking good.


SATURDAY 14TH MARCH, 1964

F.A. CUP SEMI-FINAL AT VILLA PARK, BIRMINGHAM

PRESTON NORTH END 2 (Dawson, Singleton) SWANSEA TOWN 1 (McLaughlin)

Kelly; Ross, Donnelly; Lawton (capt), Singleton, Davidson;
Wilson, Ashworth, Dawson, Spavin, Holden;

Dwyer; Evans R., Hughes; Johnson (capt), Purcell, Williams;
Jones, Draper, Thomas Todd, McLaughlin;

Referee:- J. E. Carr, Sheffield







































































Jimmy McLaughlin left beats Alan Kelly in the Preston goal to give Swansea the lead.












































































































Sunday, 5 November 2017

1963-64 - Part three (Albion and Walsall)

Posted by Tony Hutton

SATURDAY 23RD NOVEMBER, 1963

LEAGUE DIVISION ONE AT THE HAWTHORNS, WEST BROMWICH         Attendance 15,100

WEST BROMWICH ALBION 1 (Fenton) BLACKBURN ROVERS 3 (McEvoy 3)

Potter; Howe, Williams; Fraser, Jones, Simpson;
Clark, Fenton, Kaye, Hope, Carter;

Else; Bray, Newton; Clayton, England, McGrath;
Ferguson, McEvoy, Pickering, Douglas, Harrison;

Referee:- A. Holland, Barnsley
           
Brian Douglas (Blackburn Rovers)



The attendance was clearly affected by the bus strike at West Bromwich today. Albion manager Jimmy Hagan was hoping that switching Clive Clark to the right wing might bring success. Brian Douglas, operating at inside left for Rovers, rather than his normal right wing position, was soon in the action with accurate passes from midfield. Howe came to the rescue for Albion when Potter missed a cross from Ferguson by heading the ball away for a corner.
          
Switched to the right wing for this game.



Wilf Carter playing his first senior game this season came close after an individual breakaway but shot just wide of the far post. At this stage Albion were on top with their two wing halves keeping control of midfield. Mike England was the kingpin of Rovers' defence and certainly helped keep his side in the game. Rovers only real attack saw Clayton, the former England captain, have a long range effort brilliantly saved by the diving Potter.

However just before the half hour mark Rovers took the lead all against the run of play. A simple goal as Fred Else, the Blackburn keeper, hit a long ball down the middle to McEvoy, who went round Stan Jones, then drew Potter out of goal and slotted that ball past him into the net. Nine minutes later McEvoy scored another, this time thanks to a glorious pass from Douglas. McEvoy cut in from the left and as Potter came out timed his shot to perfection. Half time 0-2.

John Kaye was in the thick of it for Albion at the start of the second half but his best effort just hit the side netting. McEvoy had a chance of his hat trick as Ferguson robbed Williams and squared it inside for McEvoy just to miss the target. He missed another within a minute by blasting the ball over the cross bar from point blank range.


Finally he did complete his hat trick in the 57th minute when Douglas, with another precision pass, sent him through to score with a great shot. Certainly a hat trick to savour. Albion's supporters tried to urge their men back into the game and within five minutes they had pulled one back as Fenton scored with a brilliant header from a Carter corner, given Fred Else no chance in the Blackburn goal.

Albion tried hard to get another, but the game was up and Blackburn had proved the much better all round side. Fred Pickering who had been overshadowed by McEvoy's scoring efforts came close just before the end and then Harrison had a shot kicked off the line by an Albion defender. Douglas hit the rebound with great power but Potter stuck out a foot to save.

SATURDAY 7TH DECEMBER 1963

LEAGUE DIVISION THREE AT FELLOWS PARK, WALSALL

WALSALL 2 (Hodgkisson, Matthews) SOUTHEND UNITED 0 

White; Sharples, Gregg; Palin, Bennett, Wills;
Smith, Matthews, Wiggin, Hodgkisson, Fell;

Goy; Costello, Neal; Bentley, Watson, Ashworth;
Slater, Gilfillon, Conway, Beesley, McKinven;

Referee:- R. Egan, Cheshire


Walsall struggled throughout November and before today had not won at home since the end of October. However today saw a confident win against Southend, with two very good goals. The first came after 25 minutes when a low cross from George Meek went to Ray Wiggin, who turned the ball on to Hodgkisson to score only his second goal of the season.

Hodgkisson also had a hand in the second goal putting through Graham Matthews who ran on for twenty yards before scoring with a powerful shot past goalkeeper Goy, who has spent most of his career with Arsenal Reserves. This win left the Saddlers just below half way in the league but all the teams have little to choose between them and another few wins could seem them quickly in the top half.


SATURDAY 14TH DECEMBER, 1963

LEAGUE DIVISION THREE AT FELLOWS PARK, WALSALL

WALSALL 4 (Wiggin 2, Fincham og., Foster) LUTON TOWN 0           Attendance 3,863

White; Roper, Sharples; Palin, McPherson, Wills;
Meek, Matthews, Wiggin, Hodgkisson, Foster;

Baynham; Morton, Bramwell; Pacey, Fincham, McGuffie;
Fairchild, Smith, Turner, Reed, McKechnie;

Referee:- A.W.S. Jones, Liverpool.











SATURDAY 21ST DECEMBER, 1963

LEAGUE DIVISION THREE AT HIGHFIELD ROAD, COVENTRY

COVENTRY CITY 1  (Hale) WALSALL 0

Wesson; Sillett, Kearns; Hill, Curtis, Farmer;
Humphries, Whitehouse, Hudson, Hale, Rees;

White; Roper, Sharples; Palin, McPherson, Wills;
Meek, Mathews, Newton, Hodgkisson, Foster;

Referee:- W.E. Haynes, Wigan


                                                   Walsall's goalkeeper who came from Grimsby.

























                                                 








THURSDAY 26TH DECEMBER, 1963

LEAGUE DIVISION ONE AT THE HAWTHORNS, WEST BROMWICH

WEST BROMWICH ALBION 4 (Kaye, Clark, Fudge, Howe)
TOTTENHAM HOTSPURS 4 (Greaves 2, Smith, Jones)














1963-64 - Part two (Dennis Law sent off)

Posted by Tony Hutton

SATURDAY 16TH NOVEMBER, 1963

LEAGUE DIVISION ONE AT VILLA PARK, BIRMINGHAM          Attendance 38,000

ASTON VILLA 4 (Hateley 2, Deakin, Burrows) MANCHESTER UNITED 0

Sidebottom; Wright, Aitken; Deakin, Sleeuenhoek, Pountney;
MacEwan, Ewing, Hateley, Wylie, Burrows;

Gregg; Dunne, Cantwell; Crerand, Foulkes, Setters;
Quixall, Moore, Herd, Law, Charlton;

Referee:- J.E. Carr, Sheffield
































     
     




























1963-64 - Part one (Walsall, Blues and Villa)

Posted by Tony Hutton

TUESDAY 27TH AUGUST 1963                                 Attendance 10,000

LEAGUE DIVISION THREE AT FELLOWS PARK, WALSALL

WALSALL 1 (Fell) COLCHESTER UNITED 1 (McColl)

White; Palin, Sharples; Dudley, McPherson, Howells;
Meek, Matthews, Wiggin, Newton, Fell;

Ramage; Woods, Forbes; McCrohan, Rutter (capt.), Hunt (R.M.);
Hill, Hunt (R.R.), Stark, McColl, Wright;

Referee:- R.H. Windle, Chesterfield


Walsall started their season back in the Third Division with a new look team with newcomers White, Howells and Fell, but lost their opening game at Luton on Saturday by the only goal of the game. They were handicapped by injuries to Hodgkisson, who limped throughout that game and to McPherson who was carried off with concussion. Hodgkisson was missing tonight but McPherson was fortunately fit again. 

The team still looks a shadow of those two great promotion seasons with the newcomers still settling
in and were quite lucky to pick up a point against a determined Colchester side.

Match report from Birmingham Post.

Despite the encouragement of an opening goal after only thirty seconds Walsall could only draw their opening home match against Colchester United at Fellows Park last night. Signed from Stoke City only a matter of hours before kick off Graham Matthews proved himself full of promise and combined well with winger Fell. But these two apart the attack held little threat despite some well carved openings.

Although the opening goal was claimed by Fell, the £10,000 winger from Newcastle, much of the credit for it belonged to the last minute signing from Stoke, Graham Matthews. Taking a pass from Dudley Matthews raced down the middle and drew the Colchester defence before slipping the ball across to the outside left who scored with a shot on the run. 

All four of Walsall's new men were impressing with Matthews easily the smartest forward on the field
and carrying a strong shot. His speed and quickness of thought often proved too much for his own centre forward Wiggin. The game was almost half an hour old when Matthews almost doubled Walsall's advantage with a lob shot which Ramage did well to cover. It was completely against the run of play when Colchester drew on level terms through McColl. 

A long dropping centre from outside right Hill found White at the wrong side of the Walsall goal and McColl had no trouble in heading into the net. Five minutes from the interval Stark was spoken to by the referee following a heavy tackle on Meek. This was the signal for an all out onslaught on the Colchester goal but the interval arrived without further addition to the score.

The second period could well have followed the pattern of the first with an early goal for Walsall when Fell missed the target by inches. For a time it was almost a case of Walsall shooting in but Colchester broke away for McColl to put just wide of an unguarded goal. Luck was on Walsall's side again when goalkeeper White managed to kick a shot from Hunt (B) wide of goal as he was falling backwards. White saved the day for Walsall two minutes from the end with a brilliant clearance from McColl's equally brilliant header.  


THURSDAY 3RD OCTOBER, 1963

LEAGUE CUP SECOND ROUND AT FELLOWS PARK, WALSALL

WALSALL 1 (Newton) IPSWICH TOWN 0

White; Palin, Gregg: Dudley, McPherson, Howells;
Meek, Matthews, Wiggin, Newton, Fell;

Bailey; Carberry, Bolton; Thrower, Baxter, Dougan;
Stephenson, Colrain, Moran, Hegan, Blackwood;

Referee:- M.A. Fussey, Retford.






























SATURDAY 5TH OCTOBER, 1963

LEAGUE DIVISION ONE AT ST ANDREWS, BIRMINGHAM

BIRMINGHAM CITY 0 EVERTON 2 (Kay, Temple)

Withers; Lynn, Green; Foster, Smith, Hennessey;
Hellawell, Thomson, Harley, Beard, Auld;

West; Parker, Brown; Gabriel, Labone, Kaye;
Scott, Stevens, Young, Vernon, Temple;

Referee:- H. P. Hackney, Barnsley


The Blues are struggling near the foot of the table after a poor start to the season, winning only three of their ten games so far. They are also out of the League Cup having been beaten by Norwich and also were recently thrashed 6-1 at White Hart Lane by top of the table Spurs.

Tonight's game showed little improvement against league champions Everton who were far too good for them. The visitors were unluckily knocked out of the European Cup by the powerful Inter Milan side loosing only 1-0 away and holding the Italian champions to a goal less draw at Goodison Park.

Tonight they did not need to extend themselves too much and goals from Tony Kaye and Derek Temple were enough to give them the points. Their defence led by Brian Labone looks particularly strong and Blues newcomers Alex Harley from Man. City and Bobby Thomson from Villa rarely got a look in.


SATURDAY 19TH OCTOBER, 1963

LEAGUE DIVISION ONE AT VILLA PARK, BIRMINGHAM

ASTON VILLA 2 (Hateley 2) ARSENAL 1 (McLeod)

Sims; Wright, Aitken; Crowe, Sleeuwenhoek, Tindall;
MacEwan, Woosnam, Hateley, Burrows, Ewing;

McKechnie; Magill, McCullough; Brown, Ure, Groves;
MacLeod, Strong, Baker, Barnwell, Armstrong;

Referee:- A. Holland, Barnsley


The match programme remembered an epic game between these two teams which took place in November 1932 when the great Arsenal side of that era were top of the league by two points. However Villa with a 5-3 win took over top spot but only briefly as Arsenal went on to win the league by four points with Villa as runners up. The star studded Arsenal side on that day was as follows:- Moss; Male, Hapgood; Hill, Roberts, John; Hulme, Jack, Lambert, James, Bastin;

Today's game was not quite of the same standard, but at least Villa, after a 4-3 defeat at neighbours West Brom. last week, came out on top. Armstrong was soon in the game for Arsenal troubling young full back Wright early on before Hateley got the ball in the net for Villa only to be penalised for hand ball. Ure, the big Scotsman, was lucky not to give away a free kick on the bye line when he pushed  young Burrows to the ground, but the referee saw nothing wrong.

Both teams had chances but it looked as if the first half would be goal less until right winger MacLeod raced through a gap in the Villa defence, cut inside and hit a fine shot past Nigel Sims to give Arsenal the lead. Half time 0-1.


Wing half Tindall got in a fine shot early in the second half but McKechnie dived full length to save. It was puzzling to see why Villa had switched Ewing and Burrows at half time with Burrows moving out to the left wing. Burrows then went down injured and Brown sportingly kicked the ball out of play for him to receive attention. Soon afterwards Ure and Hateley were both lectured by the referee after a tussle which left the Villa centre forward needing treatment.

He soon recovered and used his heading skill to put Ewing through before being brought down by the Arsenal goalkeeper. Referee Holland immediately awarded a penalty and Hateley made not mistake from the spot kick after 57 minutes. Villa claimed another penalty soon afterwards when Hateley was brought down by Brown but referee Holland already unpopular with the Villa fans, waved play on.
To make things worse he awarded nothing to Villa when Sims was laid out in an Arsenal attack.


Villa were on top for quite a while before Arsenal fought back and after some defensive blunders Sims was called upon to make a great save from Armstrong. Then Sims had to complain about a poor back pass from MacEwan which nearly conceded a goal. After this period of sustained pressure from the visitors Villa managed to turn the tables with the winning goal.

The enthusiastic Ewing who chased what  appeared to be a lost cause managed to intercept an attempted clearance and put Burrows away down the left. He sent across a perfect cross which beat the goalkeeper and left Hateley a simple task to side foot it into the net with only five minutes remaining.



On the 23rd October 1963 to celebrate the Football Association's centenary, a match was played at Wembley between England and a FIFA Rest of the World side. England came out winners 2-1 with Jimmy Greaves scoring the winning goal in the last minute. Dennis Law scored an equaliser for FIFA after Terry Paine had put England ahead. The game was notable for a brilliant goalkeeping performance by Lev Yashin of Russia. Here is the star studded FIFA side.




SATURDAY 26TH OCTOBER, 1963

LEAGUE DIVISION THREE AT FELLOWS PARK, WALSALL

WALSALL 1 (Palin) OLDHAM ATHLETIC 1 (Williams)           Attendance 10,336

White; Roper, Gregg; Palin, Bennett, Wills;
Smith, Matthews, O'Neill, Newton, Fell;

Bolland; Taylor, Marshall; Frizzell, Williams, Seivewright;
Barlow, Bowie, Lister, Colquhoun, Whitaker;

Referee:- N.A.S. Matthews, Bicester



Goalkeeper Bolland was soon in action for Oldham, first taking a cross from Palin and then, following a corner, he saved a header from Newton with a brilliant diving save. O'Neill missed a great chance to put the Saddlers ahead when put through by Newton but the centre forward was slow in bringing the ball under control and his feeble shot was easily held by Bolland. Soon afterwards Matthews hit a low 25 yard drive which beat the goalkeeper but rebounded off a post.

After Palin had gone close with a 30 yard effort he put Walsall ahead from the penalty spot when right back Taylor handled the ball in trying to clear a high centre from winger Smith. This was in the 22nd minute and Walsall nearly made it two a minute later when O'Neill's point blank effort was blocked on the line by a defender. Walsall continued to dominate for the rest of the half whereas the Oldham forwards came unstuck on the edge of the penalty area against a firm Walsall defence.
Half time 1-0.

Two minutes into the second half and there was an amazing escape for Oldham when Palin ran through after a fine Matthews pass. The defenders waited for an off side whistle which never came and Palin lobbed the ball over the goalkeeper's head only to see his effort hit the crossbar and rebound into the keeper's hands.

Oldham now came back into the game and Lister went close with a header from Barlow's cross. Then Lister again was unlucky when his shot hit Wills in the face on the line and rebounded to goalkeeper White. Then Bowie headed the ball into the net from a Whitaker centre but the referee ruled that the Walsall goalkeeper had been taken out off the ball.

The visitors eventually got a deserved equaliser for their second half pressure when centre half Williams came upfield and was able to hit the ball into an empty net as White raced out in an unsuccessful attempt to reach a poor back pass from Roper.

MONDAY 28TH OCTOBER 1963                                       Attendance 3,000

LEAGUE CUP SECOND ROUND, SECOND REPLAY AT VILLA PARK, BIRMINGHAM

HUDDERSFIELD TOWN 2 (McHale, Massie) PLYMOUTH ARGYLE 1 (Malloy)

Report from Birmingham Post.

This league cup second replay drew only 3,000 to Villa Park last night and the scrappy, at times boring, tussle hardly merited a larger audience. Huddersfield won because they possessed more skill in attack but they might have been caught at the post when a Plymouth rally threatened to wipe out the Yorkshire side's 2-0 lead. Now Huddersfield go to Workington for their third round tie and perhaps travel weary Plymouth are grateful they do not face another long journey. But Argyle always fought keenly and only their early inability to finish promising moves spoilt their hopes.

With O'Neill the former Villa inside forward, always prominent they managed more attacks than the Northerners but their shooting generally provided more danger to the supporters on the terraces than to the Huddersfield goalkeeper. When Huddersfield swept into the game they were well served by the former England winger O'Grady and his partner Massie. It was Massie who took advantage of a blunder by McAnearney to chip the ball past Leiper for Huddersfield's first goal in twelve minutes.

The rest of the first half play was pointless and the only time the crowd was heard was when West Bromwich referee, Mr W. Clements, took the name of O'Neill. Thanks mainly to an improvement by the Huddersfield forwards the second half had more entertainment value. McHale superbly pulled down a good long cross from O'Grady to hit Huddersfield's second goal after 72 minutes. And in a bright 15 minutes Huddersfield also hit the crossbar - White was the unlucky forward - and missed two simple openings.

When Maloy slammed home a fine shot for Plymouth in the 81st minute, Huddersfield might have been regretting those misses. Plymouth moving more briskly into the open spaces threatened to force the game into extra time but Huddersfield finally scrambled through to end a 300 minute tie.



SATURDAY 9TH NOVEMBER 1963                    Attendance 11,961

LEAGUE DIVISION THREE AT FELLOWS PARK, WALSALL

WALSALL 0 QUEENS PARK RANGERS 2 (Lazarus, Graham)

White; Roper, Gregg; Palin, Howells, Wills;
Meek, Mason, O'Neill, Matthews, Fell;

Springett; Brady (P), Angell; Keen, Brady (R), Malcolm;
Lazarus, Bedford, Leary, Graham, McQuade;

Referee:- P. Bye, Bedford.

After a fine run of eleven games without defeat Walsall went down last weekend 3-0 to Bristol Rovers at Eastville, but they can take comfort in the performance of the many youngsters now entering the side. They lost again today against a strong Rangers side, who are struggling in the bottom half of the table. Walsall on the other hand are now in eleventh place.

Match report from Birmingham Post.

Walsall lost their second successive match despite doing sufficient attacking to have chalked up a five or six goal winning margin against far from impressive opponents. Even during their recent run of ten games without defeat, Walsall's need for a goal scoring centre forward was very obvious and the return of O'Neill after injury did little to lessen that need. In this game Walsall had at least ten chances that should have been converted into goals. The nearest they came to scoring was when Fell put a 20 yard shot against the far upright.

A goal from Lazarus gave Rangers the lead after 52 minutes. Receiving the ball well inside his own half the former Wolves player danced his way around four defenders before scoring. This inspired Walsall to greater effort but there was no improvement in finishing. Six Walsall men all failed to get the ball into the net from almost under the crossbar on one occasion. Five minutes from the end the Walsall defence presented the ball to Graham, who had the simplest of tasks to slide it past White.